id,summary,reporter,owner,description,type,status,milestone,component,version,severity,resolution,keywords,cc
11043,test test_tools_test fails if char is unsigned,Ed Vogel <edward.vogel@…>,Gennadiy Rozental,"Greetings,

(I hope it's OK to report this kind of thing)

I believe there is a problem with the boost test library test
test_tools_test.

Part of that test is:

    char ch1 = -2;
    char ch2 = -3;
    BOOST_CHECK_EQUAL(ch1, ch2);

The line in the .pattern file that corresponds to this is:

376: error in ""test_BOOST_CHECK_EQUAL"": check ch1 == ch2 failed [0xfffffffe != 0
xfffffffd]

While this is fine if char is a signed type, I believe it is wrong if
char is unsigned.  In this case the output should be:

......check ch1 == ch2 failed [0xfe != 0xfd]

Not a big deal, but the test could be updated to use a different
pattern file (as the errors_handling_test does) in this case.


It's interesting I did not find any general boost configuration macros
for systems that chose char to be unsigned.

Thank you for your time,

Ed Vogel
",Bugs,closed,To Be Determined,test,Boost 1.56.0,Problem,wontfix,,