Boost C++ Libraries: Ticket #6644: Windows: auto_link.hpp incorrectly errors with "Mixing a dll boost library with a static runtime is a really bad idea..."

attachment set

noloader@… — Thu, 01 Mar 2012 23:48:14 GMT

attachment → static-dynamic.txt

Various settings for EXE, DLL, staic and dynamic runtime linking

noloader@… — Thu, 01 Mar 2012 23:51:20 GMT

Second try with sample defines.

#if defined(BOOST_OS_WINDOWS) && defined(_MT) && !defined(_DLL)
# define BOOST_OS_WINDOWS_STATIC 1
#elif defined(BOOST_OS_WINDOWS) && defined(_MT) && defined(_DLL)
# define BOOST_OS_WINDOWS_DYNAMIC 1
#elif defined(BOOST_OS_WINDOWS)
# pragma warning("Neither static nor dynamic runtime linking has been picked up")
#endif

anonymous — Fri, 02 Mar 2012 01:08:12 GMT

Forgot to add....

When I build a static LIB (not DLL) using static runtime linking, Boost compiles correctly. So I'm not sure where the leap is made that "I'm building a DLL (with static linking), so I must want to use Boost as a DLL"

noloader@… — Fri, 02 Mar 2012 02:44:41 GMT

Undefining BOOST_DYN_LINK in my project - no joy.

noloader@… — Fri, 02 Mar 2012 03:22:49 GMT

//
// auto_link.hpp
// select linkage opt:
//
#if (defined(_DLL) || defined(_RTLDLL)) && defined(BOOST_DYN_LINK)
#  define BOOST_LIB_PREFIX
#elif defined(BOOST_DYN_LINK)
#  error "Mixing a dll boost library with a static runtime is a really bad idea..."
#else
#  define BOOST_LIB_PREFIX "lib"
#endif

The above appears broken. I just verified _DLL is *not* defined. Additionally, I did *not* define BOOST_DYN_LINK. I don't know about _RTLDLL, but I did not define it either.

Finally, there does not appear to be a BOOST_STATIC_LINK that I can define.

status changed; resolution set

John Maddock — Fri, 02 Mar 2012 13:30:35 GMT

status new → closed
resolution → worksforme

I suspect you have BOOST_DYN_LINK defined somewhere in your project settings (or those inherited by your project which can be hard to track down). Take a look at the command line tab in the IDE to see what's set.

For me I have:

/I"M:\data\boost\trunk" /ZI /nologo /W3 /WX- /Od /Oy- /D "WIN32" /D "_DEBUG" /D "_CONSOLE" /Gm /EHsc /RTC1 /MTd /GS /fp:precise /Zc:wchar_t /Zc:forScope /Yu"StdAfx.h" /Fp"Debug\dll_test.pch" /Fa"Debug\" /Fo"Debug\" /Fd"Debug\vc100.pdb" /Gd /analyze- /errorReport:queue

And building the following as a DLL:

#include "stdafx.h"
#define BOOST_LIB_DIAGNOSTIC
#include <boost/regex.hpp>
void f()
{
   boost::regex e("abc");
}

Builds just fine and links to: libboost_regex-vc100-mt-sgd-1_49.lib.

If you have a self contained test case (including the IDE project files) that reproduces please reopen, but please check the actual command line passed to the compiler first.... Oh and double check that boost/config/user.hpp hasn't been modified.

anonymous — Sat, 03 Mar 2012 18:52:46 GMT

Replying to johnmaddock:

I suspect you have BOOST_DYN_LINK defined somewhere in your project settings (or those inherited by your project which can be hard to track down). Take a look at the command line tab in the IDE to see what's set.

Actually, its not defined by me. Below is a search of the term. It only shows up in Boost gear.

Find all "BOOST_DYN_LINK", Subfolders, Find Results 1, "Entire Solution"

C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\boost-trunk\boost\config\auto_link.hpp(23):BOOST_DYN_LINK: Optional: when set link to dll rather than static library.
C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\boost-trunk\boost\config\auto_link.hpp(346):#if (defined(_DLL)

defined(_RTLDLL)) && defined(BOOST_DYN_LINK)

C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\boost-trunk\boost\config\auto_link.hpp(348):#elif defined(BOOST_DYN_LINK) C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\boost-trunk\boost\config\auto_link.hpp(414):#if defined(BOOST_DYN_LINK) C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\boost-trunk\boost\config\auto_link.hpp(415):# undef BOOST_DYN_LINK Matching lines: 5 Matching files: 1 Total files searched: 233

attachment set

noloader@… — Sat, 03 Mar 2012 19:09:12 GMT

attachment → BOOST_DYN_LINK.png

Boost is defining BOOST_DYN_LINK somewhere

anonymous — Sat, 03 Mar 2012 19:14:28 GMT

Replying to johnmaddock:

I suspect you have BOOST_DYN_LINK defined somewhere in your project settings

See attached. Boost is manipulating (or doing something with) BOOST_DYN_LINK in at least 30 files.

Take a look at the command line tab in the IDE to see what's set.

As requested (I removed the list of file names):

cl /Od /I "../esapi" /I "../errors" /I "../reference" /I "../deps" /I "C:\Documents and Settings\All Users" /I "C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\boost-trunk" /D "WIN32" /D "_DEBUG" /D "_WINDOWS" /D "_USRDLL" /D "_STATIC_CPPLIB" /D "ESAPI_MS_DLL_EXPORTS" /D "_WINDLL" /D "_UNICODE" /D "UNICODE" /Gm /EHsc /RTC1 /MTd /Fo"C:\Documents and Settings\Jeffrey Walton\Desktop\owasp-esapi-c++\VS2008
Esapi-Windows\Temp\Debug\x86\esapi-dll
" /Fd"C:\Documents and Settings\Jeffrey Walton\Desktop\owasp-esapi-c++\VS2008
Esapi-Windows\Temp\Debug\x86\esapi-dll\vc90.pdb"

This appears to be a Boost configuration problem.

Steven Watanabe — Sat, 03 Mar 2012 19:44:38 GMT

BOOST_DYN_LINK is an internal macro used by the auto link machinery. The user level macros are BOOST_ALL_DYN_LINK and BOOST_<library name>_DYN_LINK.

anonymous — Wed, 07 Mar 2012 09:19:27 GMT

Using your command line and the test program I posted above the output message I see is:

Linking to lib file: libboost_regex-vc100-mt-sgd-1_49.lib

which is the static regex lib as expected/required.

As Steven has correctly pointed out (my bad) BOOST_DYN_LINK is an internal macro set just before including the auto-link machinery. For regex it is only set if BOOST_REGEX_DYN_LINK or BOOST_ALL_DYN_LINK are defined: these are user settable macros, we don't set them.

Try adding:

#if defined(BOOST_ALL_DYN_LINK) || defined(BOOST_REGEX_DYN_LINK)
#error "Oops"
#endif

Right before you include boost.regex in your code, my guess is the error will be triggered, and then you just have to figure out where those defines are coming from.

HTH, John.

george@… — Fri, 16 Nov 2012 21:31:49 GMT

#define BOOST_PYTHON_STATIC_LIB before including <boost/python.hpp> in your project. Default for Python lib is dynamic linking. I'm using Boost 1.52.

darthpjb@… — Sun, 05 Jul 2015 03:50:07 GMT

I can both confirm that this issue is still present - and also that it is still caused by boost-python. If BOOST_PYTHON_STATIC_LIB is not defined, python defines BOOST_DYN_LINK - and prevents static linking of all boost libraries.

status changed; resolution deleted

darthpjb@… — Sun, 05 Jul 2015 04:04:18 GMT

status closed → reopened
resolution worksforme

Apologies for the double-post, but this issue-tracker seems to be having a few problems at the moment.

Replying to darthpjb@…:

I can both confirm that this issue is still present - and also that it is still caused by boost-python. If BOOST_PYTHON_STATIC_LIB is not defined, python defines BOOST_DYN_LINK - and prevents static linking of all boost libraries.

This appears when attempting to static-link boost v1.58 into a project using MSVC-12.0, using the /MT /MTD runtime-options.

without knowing that BOOST_PYTHON_STATIC_LIB must be defined, this prevents the use of boost in this scenario.

Unless there is some reason why boost-python itself cannot be statically linked (which doesn't appear to be the case), this behavior is not only highly-problematic, but potentially breaking.

owner, status, component changed

John Maddock — Tue, 07 Jul 2015 10:54:42 GMT

owner changed from John Maddock to Ralf W. Grosse-Kunstleve
status reopened → new
component config → Python

I don't have Python development files to test with, but if python.hpp is setting these macros then that's a bug.... as is dynamic linking when using the static runtime.

Reassigning.